How do you enter a conversation they say I say?

How do you enter a conversation they say I say?

Entering the Conversation

1. Briefly summarize Graff’s and Birkenstein’s overall point in “Entering the Conversation,”
2. Use one or more of the paraphrase and quotation templates from Ch. 3 to explain what “they say” and to connect what Gee says to what they say,
3. Offer your own “I say” point to close the comment.

What is a template they say I say?

Graff and Birkenstein’s templates may help you to have this conversation in a reader-‐friendly fashion, so that your thesis, supporting evidence, opposing evidence, and conclusion are clear. They Say / I Say discusses these templates more fully, and includes useful lists of them, especially in the end of the book.

What does it mean to enter the conversation they say I say?

4. Entering the Conversation

• When we say “entering the conversation,” we mean that when you are responding to a text you must put it in context and interact with it as you make your point(s).

  What is the purpose of the templates in they say I say?

  These tools are called templates: they convey specific moves in academic discourse and are used in various academic assignments: summary, analysis, synthesis, argument.

  What is the Duh formula?

  “Duh” formula: It is true that ________________; but we already knew that. You can agree by making the “twist it move”- In which you agree with the evidence that someone else has presented but show through a twist of logic that this evidence actually supports your own, contrary position.

  What is the closest cliche syndrome?

  “Closest cliche syndrome” is when a writer mistakes a cliche for the author’s view. This is sometimes the result when the writer forms an opinion on something and assumes the author feels the same way they do.

  What are I say statements?

  The two experts say that good academic writing follows a simple design called “They Say, I Say.” A paper should begin with what others have already said about the subject, or “they say.” Then, student writers present their own opinions, or “I say.” A college paper should show the writer entering a debate among experts.

  What is thesis template?

  A thesis sentence template is the basic machinery of a thesis sentence, what makes it work. It is like a car minus the hood, the doors, the en- gine, the side panels, the wheels, and the air conditioner.

  Why is entering the conversation important?

  When writing for academic purposes, you are contributing toward a larger conversation taking place among scholars. Therefore, you need to place your thoughts and input within that larger conversation.

  What is duh move?

  The “duh” move: When you disagree not with the position itself but with the assumption that it is a new or stunning revelation.

  What are return sentences?

  What are return sentences? When you return to the “they say” in your text to remind the reader what you’re responding to.

  What is a voice marker?

  Voice markers are signposts to your reader that the text coming up is comprised of ideas from a source rather than your own opinions. Whenever you include a summary, paraphrase, or direct quotation of another writer in your paper, prepare your readers for it with an introduction called the signal phrase.

  How to use they say / I say sentence templates?

  With that said, play around with these, notice how they are used in the writings of others, and determine that you will grow as an arguer this year. And remember this, too: argument is hard, and hard means we get to grow rapidly if we dare to go all in.

What’s the purpose of the they say I say template?

Remember: the templates below are meant to “be direct with [you] about the key rhetorical moves that [critical thinking] comprises” (Graff & Birkenstein, 2010). Think of them as moves in a video game or a sport–the better we get at the game or sport, the more comfortable we get with knowing when and how to use a move best.

Why did Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein write entering the conversation?

As the “Entering the Conversation: They Say/I Say by Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein” paper provides a template designed to enable readers present the authors’ ideas as they express their own in response to the author’s argument, becoming better writers with a deeper level of critical thinking. …

What’s the meaning of the they say I say sentence?

Dave cannot respond to Share requests — my apologies!) Remember: the templates below are meant to “be direct with [you] about the key rhetorical moves that [critical thinking] comprises” (Graff & Birkenstein, 2010).